Clowne: Campaigner goes to Court of Appeal in further bid for judicial review into massive housing scheme
A die-hard campaigner has appealed to the Court of Appeal in his latest bid for a judicial review into a controversial and massive housing scheme with concerns about securing ‘£1.5m’ of SEND funding arrangements from the developers after an appeal to a high court was recently refused.
Bolsover Council originally granted outline planning permission for Waystone Ltd’s application for the Clowne Garden Village housing scheme for 1,800 homes near Clowne and Barlborough, in September, 2024, after it also agreed arrangements for financial infrastructure contributions worth millions of pounds to be paid by the developer.


But the matter is still to be finalised after Clowne Garden Village Action Group Chairperson Dom Webb has submitted an appeal to one of the highest courts in the land – the Court of Appeal in London – after a request for a judicial review was refused and an initial appeal to apply for a judicial review was over-ruled by The Honourable Mr Justice Mould at Leeds High Court on April 22.
Mr Webb has argued throughout against council agreements to postpone financial contributions, amounting to nearly £1.5m, from the developer for youngsters with Special Educational Needs and Disabilities subject to the developer and scheme’s viability, and that the equality implications of the council’s decision have not been fully considered.


He said: “We welcome the many observations by Justice Mould that the applicant and council have significant responsibilities and much work to do to meet the threshold of Justice Mould’s observations relating to future reserved matters applications.
“That Justice Mould has articulated the responsibility on the council to ensure these details and safeguards come forward, or quite clearly reject any deficient application, goes directly to the heart of the matter.
“Can we make this a better application if it must go ahead. In that respect, the council and applicant can be under no illusion that shortcuts are not a liberty available to either of them going forward.”
Mr Webb is arguing that there have been errors in the principle or approach to law regarding Ground 1 matters relating to the postponed SEND contributions and equality implications which he says is why the matter will be taken forward to the Court of Appeal by a legal team on his behalf.
Bolsover Council’s planning committee originally approved Waystone Ltd’s outline planning application in September, 2024, for Clowne Garden Village and the arrangements for the S106 financial infrastructure contributions to be paid by the developer to support the area were agreed by the council in August, 2024.
The S106 arrangements included an agreement to defer a £1,463,597 payment from developer Waystone towards helping young people with SEND depending on the scheme’s future viability, and this agreed leeway for the developer has always lied at the heart of Mr Webb’s call and appeal for a judicial review.
Mr Webb’s alleged potential grounds for a judicial review have always included the council’s decision to postpone contributions for youngsters with SEND from the developer pending a viability review which he claims means that the council has wrongly allowed the developer to delay making a payment to Derbyshire County Council for SEND provisions.
He added: “SEND funding is a national crisis that has no sustainable solution on the horizon from this, or previous Governments.
“£1.5m in funding will help many families into the future so it is right that the fight to challenge its deferral by the council goes on, so that money is secured for those families that need it in the future.”
Following the refusal of Mr Webb’s first request for a judicial review into the council’s decision, earlier in the year, his solicitors submitted an appeal for the decision to be reconsidered at Leeds High Court.
The campaigner’s alleged grounds for a judicial review into the council’s decision were based on council agreements to postpone financial contributions from the developer for youngsters with SEND depending on the scheme’s viability, alleged failures to recognise the impact on wildlife habitat and the environment, and an alleged failed assessment of the impact on archaeology and heritage.
But a judge initially dismissed concerns relating to the council’s decision to defer Waystone’s financial contributions over viability, and the judge felt that the equality implications and the impact to protected species had been considered, and that there was no need to assess the cumulative impact of the Clowne Garden Village scheme alongside a separate proposed nearby water park scheme.
However, Mr Webb’s legal team filed an appeal in light of the refused judicial review arguing the judge did not fully address the equality implications of the council’s decision to defer the developer’s financial contributions on the grounds of Waystone’s viability concerns.
They also argued that the equality implications and the impact on protected species were not fully addressed and properly considered, and that there was a failure to assess the cumulative impact of Clowne Garden Village and the nearby, separate, proposed water park scheme at Whitwell Common, as well as the need to mitigate against climate change.
Mr Webb argued the council should have stated where within the ‘category of less than substantial harm’ the housing development fell according to Planning Practice Guidance despite the judge’s findings that the PPG does not apply at the outline planning stage.
He claimed his case has clearly been about protecting the most vulnerable people in society, the environment and wildlife.
Mr Webb had also argued there were significant gaps in the environmental assessment process of the planning application.
Allegations included that there had been a breach of Environmental Impact Assessment Regulations due to the lack of an assessment whether the development would impact the structural integrity of the local reservoir.
Further claims included the need to consider the scheme’s impact from greenhouse gas emissions from construction, the cumulative environmental effects of the housing and other infrastructure, and the need for a further assessment of the impact on archaeology and heritage.
But Bolsover District Council confirmed that The Honourable Mr Justice Mould ruled that claimant Mr Webb’s appeal for permission to apply for a judicial review should be refused on all grounds which the council said reaffirmed its earlier written ruling made by the court.
However, Mr Webb is now appealing to the Court of Appeal concerning ‘Ground 1’ of of his overall legal argument based on what he regards as unresolved matters concerning the council’s arrangements for the SEND contributions and the equality implications related to this decision.
Mr Webb has, however, accepted that other grounds for a judicial review have been fully considered on the facts including claims the council should have stated where within the ‘category of less than substantial harm’ the housing development fell according to Planning Practice Guidance before a judge found that the PPG does not apply at the outline planning stage.
The two other accepted matters on the facts related to a judge’s findings that the impact to protected species had been considered, and that there was no need to assess the cumulative impact of the Clowne Garden Village scheme alongside a separate proposed nearby water park scheme.
The Clowne Garden Village scheme aims to lie across 24 hectares of greenfield land and features plans for 1,800 homes, employment, community and commercial developments, green infrastructure, educational and recreational elements, a retirement village, a neighbourhood centre, a hotel, restaurant and health care and leisure uses.
Many hundreds of residents and campaigners have raised objections amid fears the scheme will lead to overcrowding, place a strain on highways, health services and education, create drainage and flooding problems and affect the countryside and wildlife with the loss of some Green Belt land.
Following the Justice Mould’s refusal for a judicial review into the scheme, Council Leader, Cllr Jane Yates, said this had reinforced the soundness of the council’s original decision and it would support the delivery of growth which she added is important for the district.
The council has also always stated that it has met its duties under the environmental impact assessment regulations and that it has been cooperating fully with relevant interested parties and it is committed to transparency.
Waystone has claimed the housing scheme will support the need for housing and it will bring highway improvements and it will offer potential for economic growth, facilities and jobs.
Bolsover Council has chosen not to comment further on the matter at this stage until the ‘due process’ has been followed.